The upcoming book by former Army Chief General M.M. Naravane has ignited a heated debate even before its official release. Originally slated for April 2024, the publication has remained under review by the Ministry of Defence (MOD) for over a year due to concerns related to national security.
Sensitive Topics Highlighted
Reports suggest that the book covers highly sensitive issues, including the Galwan Valley clashes, border tensions with China, and the controversial Agnipath military recruitment scheme. Naravane reportedly shared key insights on these topics, detailing the army’s perspectives and operational challenges.
Agnipath Scheme and Army Opinions
The former Chief has noted that the army initially expressed reservations about the Agnipath scheme. He claims that several suggestions made by military officials were not incorporated into the policy. This revelation has added fuel to debates about the scheme’s implementation and its reception within the armed forces.
Border Tensions with China
Naravane’s book also mentions China’s incursions into Indian territory. He stated that during such tense moments, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh provided the army with full discretion to act, highlighting the trust and autonomy granted to the military during critical situations.
Pre-Release Leak and Legal Concerns
Even before its official release, PDF versions and pre-print copies of the book have surfaced online. Authorities consider this a potential breach of national security. The Delhi Police registered an FIR through the Special Cell to investigate the leak. Meanwhile, the publisher, Penguin Random House India, clarified that it has not released the book officially.
Political Controversy
The book has also stirred political tensions. During the February 2026 Budget Session, opposition leader Rahul Gandhi referenced the unpublished book to criticise the government. However, the Speaker and central ministers objected, stating that discussing an unreleased book in Parliament violates official norms.
Government vs Opposition
The government views the leak as a serious security violation, while opposition parties allege that the authorities are attempting to suppress sensitive truths. Investigations are ongoing, and the final decision regarding the book’s release remains pending.
Public and Media Attention
This controversy has captured widespread public and media attention. Analysts suggest that the debate is not only about national security but also about transparency in military and government affairs. Many await the official release to understand the former Chief’s perspectives fully.
For the latest updates, click here.
